NEW DELHI, Nov 16: The Supreme Court has suspended the life imprisonment sentences of two convicts in the 2002 Bilkis Bano gangrape and murder case and granted them bail, citing the lengthy period they have already spent behind bars and legal questions pending consideration in their appeals.
A bench comprising Justices MM Sundresh and PB Varale observed that Bipin Chandra Joshi and Pradeep Mordhiya had completed more than 17 years in prison. It also took note of the severe physical disability suffered by one of the appellants while examining their applications for relief.
In its order dated October 28, which was uploaded recently, the bench stated that the appeals involved questions of both fact and law that required further examination.
“Having heard the parties, suffice it to state that the appellants have been under incarceration for a period of more than 17 years, and also the fact remains that one of the appellants has a severe handicap. Certainly, there are issues to be decided in the appeal, both on fact and law,” the court observed.
Taking these circumstances into account, the judges ordered the suspension of their sentences and granted them bail, subject to conditions to be determined by the concerned trial court.
During the proceedings, senior advocate Siddharth Luthra, representing the two convicts, argued that both had spent over 17 years in custody. He further submitted that one of them had not been named in the original First Information Report (FIR) and was implicated nearly three years after the 2002 communal violence.
Opposing the applications, Additional Solicitor General Raja Thakre strongly contested the request for bail. He argued that the trial court and the high court had carefully examined the relevant evidence and circumstances before reaching their conclusions.
Thakre also emphasised the seriousness of the crimes committed by the appellants, maintaining that the gravity of the offences should be considered while deciding whether they deserved relief.
The case relates to the brutal assault on Bilkis Bano during the communal violence that erupted in Gujarat following the Godhra train burning incident in February 2002.
At the time of the incident, Bano was 21 years old and five months pregnant. She was gangraped while attempting to flee the violence with members of her family.
Seven of her relatives were murdered during the attack, including her three-year-old daughter. The incident became one of the most widely followed cases arising from the 2002 Gujarat riots and triggered widespread demands for justice and accountability.
Joshi and Mordhiya were among the 11 individuals convicted in connection with the gangrape and multiple murders. The other convicts were Govind Nai, Ramesh Chandana, Mitesh Bhatt, Bakabhai Vohania, Kesarbhai Vohania, Jaswant Nai, Radheshyam Shah, Rajubhai Soni and Shailesh Bhatt.
The two appellants were convicted under various provisions of the Indian Penal Code, including Section 143 relating to unlawful assembly, Section 147 concerning rioting, Section 302 for murder and Section 376 for rape.
The trial court had sentenced them to rigorous imprisonment for life and imposed fines.
The latest order comes against the backdrop of the Supreme Court’s significant January 8, 2024, ruling, through which it cancelled the remission granted to all 11 convicts by the Gujarat government.
In that judgment, the apex court strongly criticised the state government for its decision to release the convicts prematurely, describing its conduct as being complicit with one of the accused and an abuse of its discretionary powers.
The court had also ruled that the Gujarat government was not competent to grant remission in the matter, as the trial had been transferred from Gujarat to Maharashtra.
Since the case was tried in Mumbai, the Supreme Court held that the Maharashtra government, rather than the Gujarat administration, had the authority to consider remission applications.
The January 2024 verdict resulted in the return of all 11 convicts to prison after their earlier release under the remission policy was overturned.
The latest decision to suspend the sentences of Joshi and Mordhiya is separate from the earlier remission proceedings and arises from their pending appeals.
Their release on bail will be governed by the conditions imposed by the trial court, while the legal challenges concerning their convictions remain subject to further consideration by the Supreme Court.