New Delhi, Nov 20: The Supreme Court on Friday declined a request for a separate hearing on a plea seeking the recall of a split verdict concerning the constitutional validity of the 2023 law governing the appointment of the Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) and Election Commissioners (ECs).
A bench comprising Chief Justice of India (CJI) Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana indicated that the recall application, along with any challenge to the reference order, could be considered by the five judge Constitution bench already constituted to examine the batch of petitions challenging the legislation.
The CJI observed that the larger bench would be competent to consider the recall application even if one of the judges who delivered the original split verdict retired before the matter was taken up.
During the proceedings, advocate Prashant Bhushan requested that the recall application be listed before the original two-judge bench comprising Justices Dipankar Datta and Satish Chandra Sharma, which delivered the divided judgment on September 23.
Bhushan argued that the application should be heard by the same judges who had passed the earlier order. He also pointed out that Justice Sharma was scheduled to retire next week, making an early listing of the matter necessary.
Raising another objection, the advocate submitted that Justice Sharma had a conflict of interest and maintained that the recall plea should be examined by the original bench rather than being placed before another judicial formation.
Responding to the submission, the CJI suggested that the five-judge bench constituted to hear the constitutional challenge could examine the application.
Bhushan, however, questioned this approach, pointing out that the reference order itself had been challenged on the ground of an alleged conflict of interest.
The CJI maintained that the objections could be presented before the Constitution bench, which would have the opportunity to consider the relevant issues while adjudicating the broader constitutional dispute.
The disagreement arises from a split verdict pronounced on September 23 by Justices Datta and Sharma on whether the challenges to the 2023 legislation should be referred to a larger bench.
The petitions primarily question the provision that excludes the Chief Justice of India from the selection committee responsible for recommending appointments to the posts of CEC and Election Commissioners.
Under the Chief Election Commissioner and Other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023, the selection committee comprises the Prime Minister, the Leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha and a Union Cabinet Minister nominated by the Prime Minister.
The petitioners have challenged this arrangement, arguing that removing the CJI from the selection process undermines the independence of the Election Commission and raises concerns about the institutional autonomy of the constitutional body.
The controversy is linked to an earlier Supreme Court judgment that had prescribed a selection mechanism involving the Prime Minister, the Leader of Opposition and the Chief Justice of India until Parliament enacted a law governing appointments.
The court had introduced this arrangement to safeguard the independence of the Election Commission and prevent the appointment process from being controlled exclusively by the executive.
Parliament subsequently enacted the 2023 legislation, replacing the judicially prescribed selection arrangement with a committee that includes a Union Cabinet Minister instead of the CJI.
The new law became the subject of multiple petitions questioning its constitutional validity and the extent of executive influence over appointments to the Election Commission.
In the September 23 split verdict, Justice Datta took the position that the constitutional challenge could be examined by a two-judge bench and did not necessarily require a reference to a larger bench.
Justice Sharma, however, favoured referring the matter to a five-judge Constitution bench, considering the substantial constitutional questions involved and their implications for the independence of the Election Commission.
The disagreement between the two judges resulted in a divided opinion on the question of reference, leading to the matter being placed before a larger judicial formation.
The latest proceedings concerned the subsequent attempt to recall the reference-related decision and the request to have that application heard separately by the original judges.
The three-judge bench did not agree to the demand for an independent listing and instead indicated that the Constitution bench could address the objections along with the main constitutional challenge.
The issue is significant because the Election Commission plays a central role in conducting free and fair elections, overseeing electoral processes and ensuring compliance with constitutional and statutory requirements.
The independence of the institution and the transparency of appointments to its senior positions have therefore become important subjects of constitutional debate.
The five-judge Constitution bench will now have the opportunity to examine the legal questions surrounding the 2023 legislation, including the challenge to the composition of the selection committee.
The outcome could have wider implications for the institutional independence of the Election Commission and the framework governing the appointment of its top officials.