SC Says Yamuna Pollution Has Worsened Despite Massive Spending on River Cleaning

Supreme Court directs CPCB to monitor water quality across states and districts, warning that untreated sewage and industrial waste must be controlled at the source, with penalties for authorities responsible for deterioration.

NEW DELHI, Nov 16: The Supreme Court has expressed serious concern over the deteriorating condition of the Yamuna, observing that pollution in the river has continued to increase despite substantial public expenditure on cleaning and restoration projects.

Directing the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) to strengthen its monitoring mechanism, the court ordered regular assessments of water quality at points where the Yamuna and its major drains enter and leave different states, Union territories and districts.

In an order dated November 4, a bench comprising Justices Manoj Misra and Manmohan emphasised that industrial discharge and untreated sewage must be controlled at their source to achieve meaningful improvements in the river’s condition.

The bench observed that constructing additional sewage treatment plants alone would not resolve the problem unless the authorities addressed the underlying failures in urban sanitation and wastewater management.

“This court is of the opinion that everything that is wrong with the civic administration in towns, cities and villages situated along the banks of the river is reflected in the poor health of the river and in the 520 drains that discharge wastewater into the Yamuna,” the bench observed.

It further noted that despite considerable financial resources being spent on river-cleaning initiatives, the pollution situation had worsened rather than improved.

The observations came during a hearing on a petition concerning the cleaning and conservation of the Yamuna.

The court stressed that preventing pollutants from entering the river must become the primary objective of government agencies instead of relying mainly on treatment measures after wastewater has already entered the drainage network.

It said untreated sewage should be intercepted and processed wherever direct prevention of discharge is not possible.

However, the bench acknowledged that effective sewage interception would remain difficult without a properly developed sewerage network, particularly in areas where stormwater and wastewater channels have been interconnected.

The court also highlighted the difficulties faced by civic authorities in unauthorised settlements and colonies developed on encroached land.

Such areas frequently lack planned road networks and sufficient space for installing underground sewage infrastructure, making it challenging to establish effective wastewater collection systems.

The bench observed that illegal and unauthorised colonies, along with jhuggi-jhopri clusters situated along drains and on the riverbed, continued to contribute to the pollution problem.

It stressed that addressing these settlements would require appropriate rehabilitation arrangements for their residents rather than treating the issue solely as an infrastructure problem.

The court also directed that authorities responsible for any deterioration in water quality while the river passes through their respective jurisdictions would face accountability measures and financial penalties.

According to the order, if water quality declines on any monitored parameter while flowing through or exiting a particular state, Union territory or district, the concerned administration would be held responsible.

The compensation or fine imposed would be deposited with the Supreme Court registry.

The bench instructed the CPCB to develop and recommend a suitable formula for calculating such financial penalties.

The monitoring exercise is intended to identify the specific geographical areas and administrative jurisdictions where contamination increases, making it easier to determine responsibility for pollution.

The Supreme Court also asked the CPCB to investigate individual pollution incidents and submit comprehensive reports identifying their causes and the corrective measures required.

These investigations would cover incidents such as fish deaths, the appearance of white foam on the river’s surface, eutrophication, algal blooms and abnormal increases in Biochemical Oxygen Demand (BOD), Chemical Oxygen Demand (COD) and Total Suspended Solids (TSS).

The court said the reports should clearly explain the reasons behind such developments and recommend appropriate remedial action.

To strengthen the monitoring process, the bench directed central and state government departments, ministries and other public institutions to provide the CPCB with all necessary administrative, technical, operational, logistical and infrastructural support.

It further ordered public and private entities involved in wastewater treatment, solid waste management and industrial effluent processing to provide immediate access to their facilities, installations and records.

The directions also cover concessionaires, plant operators and agencies responsible for managing or maintaining pollution-control infrastructure.

The court emphasised that CPCB officials and authorised third-party agencies must be allowed to conduct unannounced inspections, collect samples without prior notice, examine wastewater volumes, verify monitoring sensors and undertake technical assessments.

It also directed relevant departments and plant operators to provide unrestricted access to operational data and cooperate with the integration of their facilities into the CPCB’s centralised monitoring system within the prescribed timelines.

The matter has been scheduled for further hearing on January 13, when the court is expected to examine progress on the implementation of its directions.

Yamuna Pollution