NEW DELHI, Nov 17: Several states have called for giving weightage to Class 12 board examination marks in the National Eligibility cum Entrance Test Undergraduate (NEET-UG), placing the issue at the centre of discussions on reforming the country’s medical admission system.
The proposal was raised during consultations with the six-member High Powered Task Force headed by Nandan Nilekani, which was established to examine possible changes to major competitive examinations and address concerns surrounding the existing testing system.
Apart from incorporating school examination performance into the medical admission process, states have also suggested conducting NEET more than once a year and shifting from the traditional pen and paper format to a computer based test (CBT).
According to officials familiar with the discussions, a majority of participating states have emphasised that excessive dependence on a single entrance examination has increased the influence of coaching institutions and weakened students’ focus on regular school education.
The consultations have highlighted concerns that students preparing for medical entrance examinations frequently prioritise coaching programmes over their Class 11 and Class 12 academic responsibilities.
States have argued that recognising performance in board examinations could help restore the importance of school education and encourage students to maintain a consistent academic record instead of concentrating almost entirely on one competitive test.
The issue has also drawn attention to the growing practice of dummy schooling, in which students remain enrolled in schools but devote most of their time to coaching institutes for competitive examinations.
Officials indicated that some stakeholders believe the pressure to secure a high NEET score has contributed to this trend. Students often enrol in institutions that provide limited regular classroom engagement while depending on private coaching centres for preparation.
According to the views expressed during the consultations, incorporating Class 12 marks into the admission framework could encourage students to participate more actively in classroom learning and take their school examinations seriously.
However, the precise method of calculating board examination weightage has not been finalised. The task force is examining suggestions from different states and stakeholders before making its recommendations.
The issue is particularly significant because NEET-UG serves as the common entrance examination for undergraduate medical admissions across the country. Candidates from different education boards and academic backgrounds compete through the same national-level testing process.
Supporters of the proposed change believe that a combination of board examination performance and entrance test scores could provide a broader assessment of students’ academic abilities.
They argue that school examinations evaluate learning across subjects over an extended period, whereas a single competitive examination measures performance within a limited testing window.
Introducing an additional assessment component could potentially reduce the importance attached to one examination day. Students who experience anxiety, illness or other difficulties during the entrance test may benefit from a system that recognises their performance over a longer academic period.
At the same time, determining an appropriate weightage would require careful consideration of differences among education boards, examination patterns, marking systems and evaluation standards.
Another major proposal discussed during the consultations concerns conducting NEET more than once in a year.
States have suggested that allowing multiple attempts could reduce the pressure associated with a single annual examination and provide candidates with additional opportunities to improve their performance.
Under the existing system, students generally prepare throughout the year for one scheduled examination. A disappointing result can force them to wait for another admission cycle, often leading to another year of preparation.
The possibility of multiple examinations could offer greater flexibility to candidates and potentially reduce the psychological burden associated with the current arrangement.
It may also provide students with an opportunity to improve their scores without having to depend entirely on a single attempt.
However, introducing additional examination sessions would require substantial administrative planning. Authorities would need to ensure consistency in question difficulty, evaluation standards and examination security across different sessions.
Maintaining fairness between candidates appearing on different dates would be particularly important. Any system involving multiple attempts would need a transparent mechanism for preparing question papers, calculating scores and determining final rankings.
The task force has also examined the possibility of replacing the pen-and-paper examination with a computer-based format.
Several states have supported the transition to CBT, arguing that technology-enabled examinations could improve the management of large-scale testing and strengthen monitoring arrangements.
Officials indicated that most southern states, except Tamil Nadu, supported the computer-based format during the discussions.
Some stakeholders, however, have suggested that candidates should initially be given the option of appearing through either computer-based or traditional pen and paper examinations.
The proposed transitional arrangement is intended to help students become familiar with digital testing before a complete shift is considered.
The experience of the Joint Entrance Examination for engineering admissions was cited during discussions, as candidates were initially provided with different examination formats during the transition towards computer-based testing.
A similar approach could help NEET aspirants from different educational backgrounds adjust to the new system.
Moving towards CBT would also require significant investment in examination infrastructure. States have stressed the need for adequate computer facilities, secure testing centres and reliable technological arrangements.
Authorities would have to ensure that candidates in rural and remote areas receive the same opportunities as those living in major cities.
The availability of sufficient examination centres would be another important consideration. States have suggested establishing at least one centre in every district so that students do not have to travel long distances to appear for the entrance test.
Long-distance travel can create additional financial and logistical difficulties for candidates, particularly those belonging to economically weaker families and remote communities.
Increasing the number of accessible examination centres could reduce these difficulties and make the testing process more convenient.
The discussions have also addressed the importance of strengthening coordination between central examination agencies, state governments and district administrations.
Effective coordination would be necessary to manage examination schedules, identify suitable centres, deploy personnel and ensure that security arrangements remain consistent across locations.
Another suggestion concerns preparing examination questions closer to the scheduled test date. Stakeholders have discussed whether this approach could strengthen confidentiality and reduce the possibility of question paper leaks.
The issue of examination integrity has remained an important concern in the broader debate over competitive examination reforms. Any new arrangement would therefore need to place strong emphasis on secure question generation, data protection and monitoring mechanisms.
The Nandan Nilekani-led panel was constituted following student protests over examination-related concerns in July. Prime Minister Narendra Modi announced the high-powered task force after Dharmendra Pradhan stepped down as Education Minister following the demonstrations at Jantar Mantar on July 25.
The panel has been assigned the responsibility of examining existing examination practices and recommending measures to improve transparency, reliability and fairness.
According to officials, the task force has already completed consultations with all southern states, Jammu and Kashmir and Odisha. Discussions with northern states are scheduled to take place in the coming days.
The committee has reportedly held 18 high-level meetings and 40 consultative meetings during the initial two months of its functioning, reflecting the wide range of issues being examined.
Its report, which was initially expected in October, has been given an extended timeline until January 2027.
The extension is intended to provide additional time for consultations and a detailed examination of the suggestions received from different stakeholders.
Tamil Nadu’s position on NEET has also emerged as an important part of the discussions. The state has maintained its opposition to the common medical entrance examination and raised concerns regarding its impact on students studying under state education boards.
During the consultations, representatives from Tamil Nadu reportedly pointed to a decline in the proportion of students from the state board entering medical education compared with candidates from CBSE and ICSE backgrounds in Delhi.
The state has argued that a common entrance examination creates particular challenges for students following different academic curricula.
The debate highlights the difficulty of designing a national admission framework that maintains common standards while taking into account differences in school education across states.
Medical admissions involve a highly competitive selection process, and any proposed changes could have implications for millions of students preparing for undergraduate medical courses.
Education experts and policymakers will therefore need to examine whether board examination weightage, additional attempts and computer-based testing can be introduced without creating new inequalities.
For students, the proposed reforms could bring significant changes to the way they prepare for medical entrance examinations. Greater recognition of board examination results may encourage candidates to balance their school studies with competitive examination preparation.
Multiple attempts could provide additional flexibility, while computer-based testing may eventually change the examination experience and require students to develop familiarity with digital platforms.
Nevertheless, these proposals remain under consideration and should not be treated as confirmed changes to the existing admission process.
The final recommendations will depend on the task force’s assessment and subsequent decisions by the concerned ministries and examination authorities.
The broader objective is to develop a system that evaluates students fairly, reduces unnecessary examination pressure and strengthens confidence in the country’s competitive testing framework.
As consultations continue, the proposed changes are expected to remain an important part of the national discussion on improving medical education admissions and ensuring equal opportunities for aspiring doctors.