Independent , Honest and Dignified Journalism

BTS Wins US Copyright Case as Separate Dispute Over Song SWIM Continues

A Virginia federal court has dismissed a songwriter's amended complaint against the K-pop group and its agency for failing to establish sufficient legal grounds, although another copyright dispute involving the group's hit track remains unresolved.

SEOUL, Nov 2: South Korean music sensation BTS has secured a significant legal victory in the United States after a federal court dismissed a copyright infringement lawsuit filed against the group, its management company Big Hit Music and other associated entities.

The US District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia dismissed an amended complaint submitted by Melissa Mays, who had alleged that BTS and its team used her unreleased musical compositions without obtaining permission.

The ruling, issued on October 22, favoured BTS, Big Hit Music, HYBE and HYBE America, bringing the particular legal dispute to an end after the complainant failed to establish sufficient grounds for her allegations.

The development was reported on November 2 and has attracted attention among international music followers, particularly because the group has also been involved in a separate copyright dispute concerning its song SWIM.

According to reports from South Korean media outlets, Mays filed her original complaint on August 25, alleging that musical material belonging to her had been used without authorisation.

However, the initial filing did not provide sufficient details to establish a legally valid copyright infringement claim. The court subsequently dismissed the complaint in September and gave the plaintiff an opportunity to submit an amended version containing additional information.

Judge Leonie Brinkema directed Mays to revise her filing and provide the necessary details by October 9.

The plaintiff submitted the amended complaint on October 8. However, the revised filing was also found insufficient to meet the legal requirements of the case.

The court consequently dismissed the amended complaint, ruling in favour of the defendants.

The decision represents an important development for BTS and its associated music companies, which have consistently maintained that allegations of unauthorised use of musical compositions must be supported by appropriate evidence.

The case also demonstrates the importance of establishing a clear legal basis when pursuing copyright claims in the music industry.

Copyright disputes involving musical compositions can involve complicated questions concerning originality, ownership, access to previously created material and similarities between different recordings.

A claimant generally needs to establish a legally recognisable copyright interest and provide sufficient factual grounds to support allegations of infringement.

In the present case, the court’s decision followed the failure of the amended complaint to address the deficiencies identified in the original filing.

The dismissal, however, should not be confused with a separate legal dispute involving BTS’s song SWIM, which remains a different matter.

That controversy emerged after three American songwriters, Steve Cooper, John Sandler and Graylin Johnson, filed a copyright infringement lawsuit in July 2026 in the US District Court for the Central District of California.

The composers alleged that SWIM, the title track from BTS’s fifth studio album ARIRANG, contained similarities to an unreleased demonstration track they had created in March 2025.

Their complaint named HYBE, HYBE America, Big Hit Music and individuals associated with the composition of the BTS song as defendants.

The BTS members themselves were not named as defendants in that separate California lawsuit.

The songwriters claimed that their earlier composition shared several musical elements with the track released by BTS. These allegedly included similarities involving the melody, chorus, harmony, rhythm and lyrics.

To support their allegations, the complainants reportedly submitted an analysis prepared by musicologist Alexander Stewart.

The expert assessment highlighted what the plaintiffs described as similarities between the two compositions and was presented as part of their copyright infringement claim.

The songwriters are seeking damages and a share of the revenue generated by the disputed track.

Big Hit Music has rejected the allegations and maintained that SWIM was independently created.

The agency has described the lawsuit as a unilateral claim and stated that it intends to defend its position through the legal process.

The two proceedings therefore involve different plaintiffs, claims and judicial proceedings. While the Virginia case filed by Mays has been dismissed, the California dispute concerning SWIM remains separate and should not be treated as having been resolved by the latest ruling.

The legal developments come at an important time for BTS, which has returned to full-group activities following the completion of mandatory military service by its members.

The seven-member group, comprising RM, Jin, Suga, J-Hope, Jimin, V and Jungkook, made its long-awaited comeback on March 20, 2026, with its fifth studio album, ARIRANG.

The album marked the group’s first full-length release together in nearly four years and generated considerable international interest.

Its release represented a major moment for the K-pop industry, given BTS’s influence on global music charts, streaming platforms and international concert markets.

The album contains 14 tracks and reflects the group’s musical identity while incorporating a range of contemporary sounds and influences.

SWIM, the lead single, became one of the central tracks associated with the comeback campaign. Its popularity also brought renewed attention to the creative contributions involved in producing music for internationally successful artists.

The current copyright dispute has consequently placed the song’s creation process under closer examination.

For music companies, copyright protection is an important part of the business, particularly when recordings are distributed across several countries and generate income through streaming, licensing, live performances and other commercial arrangements.

An infringement claim can potentially affect the reputation of an artist, the commercial value of a recording and the relationship between performers, composers, producers and record labels.

At the same time, allegations of copying require careful judicial examination because similarities between musical works do not automatically establish copyright infringement.

Courts generally need to consider the evidence presented by the parties, including ownership documents, the nature of the allegedly copied material and the circumstances surrounding the creation of the disputed work.

The dismissal of Mays’ complaint highlights the importance of providing adequate legal and factual information before a copyright case can proceed.

For BTS and its management, the outcome removes one legal challenge, although the separate California proceedings mean that the broader copyright discussion surrounding SWIM is not over.

Beyond the courtroom developments, BTS continues to pursue its international musical activities.

The group launched its 2026–27 ARIRANG World Tour in April, beginning with performances in Goyang, South Korea.

The tour includes performances across Asia, North America, South America, Europe and Australia, with a schedule covering 34 regions and 85 shows.

The extensive programme reflects the group’s continued international popularity and the strong demand for its live performances following the reunion.

The members’ return to touring has also strengthened the visibility of Korean popular music across international markets, with fans travelling between countries to attend performances.

The group’s activities have continued to attract attention from music critics, entertainment publications and industry observers.

For HYBE and Big Hit Music, the latest court ruling is a welcome development amid the legal and commercial responsibilities associated with managing one of the world’s most recognised music acts.

The company will nevertheless have to address the separate allegations concerning SWIM through the appropriate legal process.

The outcome of that case could have implications for the parties involved, particularly regarding ownership claims, songwriting credits and the protection of musical compositions.

For now, the dismissal of Mays’ amended complaint provides BTS with a favourable result in one US legal proceeding.

The development also reinforces the distinction between an allegation and a legally established infringement, with courts requiring adequate supporting material before claims can proceed.

As the group continues its world tour and promotional activities, attention will remain on both its musical achievements and the outstanding legal dispute surrounding its latest major release.

WhatsApp Channel