Thiruvananthapuram June 02 : Congress MP and senior party leader Shashi Tharoor has weighed in on the ongoing debate surrounding the rendition of Vande Mataram at official functions, expressing reservations about proposals that call for the complete version of the national song to be played multiple times during public events.
Addressing media persons in the Kerala capital, Tharoor clarified that his remarks should not be interpreted as opposition to Vande Mataram. Instead, he argued that the current discussion revolves around the manner and frequency of its performance rather than the song itself, which he described as a respected national symbol.
The parliamentarian observed that for decades, public ceremonies across the country have followed a broadly accepted convention in which a shorter, familiar portion of the song is rendered during formal occasions. According to him, this practice has allowed audiences to participate respectfully while preserving the ceremonial significance of the composition.
Tharoor noted that recent suggestions advocating the performance of all five verses at both the opening and closing of official programmes have generated confusion and disagreement. He questioned whether such a requirement serves any practical purpose, particularly at shorter events where attendees may already be standing through multiple ceremonial segments.
Referring to differing interpretations from constitutional authorities and the state administration, he pointed out that the issue remains largely a matter of convention rather than a clearly defined legal obligation. He suggested that if conflicting views continue to persist, the matter may eventually require formal clarification through appropriate channels.
The Congress Working Committee member emphasized that patriotism and respect for national symbols should not be measured solely by the length of ceremonial performances. He maintained that citizens can honour the national song without necessarily endorsing extensive protocols that may not have historical precedent.
Drawing from his personal experience at a recent public programme attended by senior dignitaries, Tharoor recalled an occasion where the complete rendition was played more than once. He remarked that many attendees found it difficult to remain engaged throughout the lengthy proceedings, particularly because several sections of the composition are not widely known among the general public.
According to Tharoor, the traditionally performed portion of Vande Mataram has long enjoyed widespread acceptance and carries immense emotional and cultural significance. He argued that retaining this approach would preserve respect for the song while avoiding unnecessary complications during official functions.
The remarks come amid a broader discussion in Kerala over ceremonial practices at government and institutional events. The issue has sparked debate among political leaders, administrators, and cultural observers regarding the balance between national traditions and practical considerations.
Despite his criticism of the proposed format, Tharoor reiterated that he holds the national song in high regard and has no objection to its performance at appropriate occasions. He expressed hope that the matter would be settled through dialogue and consensus rather than prolonged controversy.
As discussions continue, the debate has once again highlighted differing perspectives on how national symbols should be incorporated into public ceremonies while ensuring that longstanding traditions and public convenience remain in harmony.