Independent , Honest and Dignified Journalism

Italian Leader’s India Speech Sparks Political Backlash at Home

Forza Italia leader Deborah Bergamini questions Giacomo Filibeck's criticism of the BJP at the Bharat Summit, calling it inappropriate to interfere in India's domestic political affairs.

LONDON, Nov 16: An Italian political representative’s criticism of the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) during a recent visit to India has triggered a political controversy back home, with a senior member of Italy’s ruling coalition questioning the appropriateness of commenting on the internal affairs of a friendly nation.

Deborah Bergamini, national deputy secretary of the Forza Italia party, on Sunday criticised Giacomo Filibeck, Secretary General of the Party of European Socialists, over his remarks at the Bharat Summit 2026, held in Hyderabad.

During the November 13-14 event, organised by the Indian National Congress (INC), Filibeck voiced support for Congress leader Rahul Gandhi’s campaign against alleged discrepancies in India’s electoral rolls. He also raised the slogan “Vote Chor Gaddi Chhod”, which calls on those accused of stealing votes to leave office.

Responding to his remarks through a social media post, Bergamini said an Italian representative associated with the European socialist and democratic political grouping had criticised Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s BJP at an event hosted by the Congress.

Without directly naming Filibeck, she questioned the decision to intervene in India’s domestic political discussions.

Bergamini maintained that democratic societies allow individuals to express their opinions and raise allegations, provided they are capable of substantiating their claims.

However, she described interference in the internal political debate of a friendly country as inappropriate, particularly given the strong diplomatic and economic relationship between Rome and New Delhi.

Italy and India, she noted, share a special strategic partnership and have expanded cooperation across several sectors.

Bergamini further argued that European countries should refrain from lecturing India on democratic principles, pointing out that the country has approximately 970 million voters.

She stressed that India has its own democratic institutions and judicial system, adding that political disputes and allegations must be addressed through established constitutional and democratic procedures.

Forza Italia is a constituent of Italy’s ruling coalition, headed by Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni, making Bergamini’s intervention particularly significant in the context of the two countries’ diplomatic relations.

Speaking at the Hyderabad summit, Filibeck had praised Rahul Gandhi’s efforts to highlight alleged irregularities in electoral rolls and defend the democratic principle of “one person, one vote”.

He also referred to the Congress-led demonstrations at Ramlila Maidan in New Delhi, held around two weeks before the summit, as an example of public participation in defending democratic rights.

Filibeck said Gandhi’s campaign for transparent voter lists, along with the participation of thousands of demonstrators, reflected the importance of citizens standing up to protect democratic institutions.

The controversy comes amid an ongoing political confrontation in India over the Congress-led “vote chori” campaign. The opposition has accused the BJP and the Election Commission of India of electoral irregularities, alleging that the integrity of voter lists and the electoral process has been compromised.

The BJP and the Election Commission have repeatedly dismissed these allegations as baseless.

Filibeck’s comments have now added an international dimension to the domestic political dispute, while Bergamini’s response has underlined the importance of respecting India’s democratic institutions and its political sovereignty.

WhatsApp Channel