Independent , Honest and Dignified Journalism

UN-Backed Talks Explore Possible Rules for Lethal Autonomous Weapons

Governments gather in Geneva to consider launching negotiations on a legally binding agreement governing killer robots and AI-powered weapons, amid divisions among major military powers over international restrictions.

GENEVA, Nov 16: The growing use of artificial intelligence in modern warfare is set to come under renewed international scrutiny as government representatives gather in Geneva this week to discuss possible regulations on lethal autonomous weapons, including armed drones and robotic systems capable of selecting and attacking targets without direct human intervention.

The discussions could determine whether countries move towards formal negotiations on a legally binding international agreement to regulate these increasingly sophisticated weapons or postpone efforts to establish restrictions.

The debate has gained urgency as technological advances make it increasingly possible for machines to perform military operations with limited human involvement. The central concern is whether decisions involving human life and death should ever be delegated to autonomous systems and how governments can ensure accountability when such weapons are used.

Pope Leo XIV, United Nations Secretary-General Antonio Guterres and several international advocacy organisations have highlighted the ethical, humanitarian and security implications of allowing artificial intelligence to make independent decisions about lethal force.

Although reports indicate that armed drones with autonomous targeting capabilities have been deployed in limited instances in conflict zones, including Ukraine and the Middle East, their widespread use remains a major concern for governments and humanitarian organisations.

For years, discussions surrounding so-called killer robots have raised alarming possibilities, including autonomous aircraft identifying and attacking individuals without human approval. However, despite repeated international meetings and growing public concern, governments have yet to establish a comprehensive agreement restricting these weapons.

The United States and Russia, two influential military powers, remain cautious about accepting restrictions that could affect their ability to develop and deploy advanced military technologies. Their positions have complicated efforts to establish common international standards, particularly as artificial intelligence becomes increasingly important to military planning and defence strategies.
Seven nations push for formal negotiations
The issue will be discussed during the seventh review conference of the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons, being held at the United Nations offices in Geneva.

Delegates will examine whether the international community should begin formal negotiations on regulating autonomous weapons systems.

Supporters of an international agreement acknowledge that reaching consensus will be difficult, particularly because several powerful countries remain reluctant to accept restrictions. However, they argue that previous international agreements demonstrate that governments can establish safeguards against particularly dangerous military technologies.

One such precedent is the agreement regulating blinding laser weapons, which showed that international cooperation on specific categories of conventional weapons is possible.

Most countries have expressed support for introducing international safeguards on autonomous weapons. The UN Secretary-General has also called for negotiations on a legally binding instrument to begin within this year, increasing pressure on governments to reach a decision.

Last month, Austria, Belgium, Brazil, Ireland, Mexico, New Zealand and Panama jointly submitted a proposal seeking the launch of negotiations on a new legally binding agreement covering autonomous weapons.

The proposal has added momentum to the campaign for international restrictions and brought the issue closer to a decisive diplomatic confrontation.

The International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) has also urged governments to ensure that human beings retain meaningful control over decisions involving the use of lethal force.

ICRC President Mirjana Spoljaric, in a statement issued on Friday, warned that countries must prevent the future of warfare from being handed over to machines.

The advocacy organisation Stop Killer Robots has claimed that around 130 countries support the introduction of new international rules governing autonomous weapons systems.

Campaigners have also stepped up public awareness efforts, launching advertisements in streets and underground transport networks in Berlin, London and Paris to highlight the potential dangers of weapons capable of operating without direct human control.
Pope and UN officials raise ethical concerns
The debate has also attracted attention from religious leaders and senior international officials, who have warned against allowing technological developments to undermine basic humanitarian principles.

In his first encyclical issued in May, Pope Leo XIV criticised what he described as a culture of power driving the global artificial intelligence race, particularly in the development of increasingly sophisticated remote warfare technologies.

He stressed that decisions concerning life and death should not be entrusted to remote artificial intelligence systems.

United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights Volker Turk has similarly urged governments to reach an urgent agreement on legally binding restrictions governing lethal autonomous weapons systems.

Turk said the international community faces important decisions about the future of armed conflicts and the extent to which human beings must remain involved in decisions concerning the use of force.

His remarks underline the growing concern that autonomous weapons could weaken accountability and create serious challenges in determining responsibility when civilians are harmed or military operations violate international humanitarian law.

Humanitarian organisations argue that meaningful human control is essential to ensuring that military operations comply with established principles of distinction, proportionality and precaution.

Without adequate safeguards, autonomous systems could make it difficult to assess the circumstances surrounding an attack and identify those responsible for unlawful decisions.
Consensus requirement creates diplomatic hurdles
Despite increasing international support for regulation, the negotiations face significant procedural and political obstacles.

Under the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons, decisions must be adopted through consensus. Consequently, even one country can prevent an agreement from being reached.

This requirement raises concerns that negotiations could produce only limited commitments or that governments may fail to agree on a formal process altogether.

Another unresolved issue involves the timeframe that would be given to negotiators to develop and finalise the proposed legal framework.

Ahead of the Geneva conference, humanitarian organisations and campaign groups expressed concern that Russia could use procedural arguments to delay or obstruct efforts to initiate formal negotiations.

Moscow, however, has defended its position, stating that it wants the conference to produce mutually acceptable outcomes and strengthen the existing international framework governing conventional weapons.

Russian Foreign Ministry spokesperson Maria Zakharova said on Wednesday that her country attached considerable importance to the successful outcome of the conference.

She also called for organisational matters to be resolved first and argued that the diplomatic process should remain free from politicisation.

However, her remarks made clear that Russia does not consider the present circumstances suitable for introducing restrictions or prohibitions on autonomous weapons.

“We consider it premature to argue that the time has supposedly come to develop restrictive or prohibitive measures concerning such systems,” Zakharova said.

Russia’s position reflects broader disagreements over how rapidly international rules should be introduced and whether existing humanitarian and weapons-control frameworks are sufficient to address emerging military technologies.
Future of warfare at a critical crossroads
The Geneva conference is being viewed as an important opportunity to determine whether international efforts to regulate autonomous weapons can move beyond years of discussions and produce concrete diplomatic action.

Supporters of a legally binding agreement believe that waiting until such systems become widely deployed could make regulation considerably more difficult.

They argue that governments must establish clear boundaries before technological developments outpace international law and create new risks for civilians and military personnel.

Opponents of immediate restrictions, meanwhile, remain concerned about limiting technological innovation and national defence capabilities at a time when artificial intelligence is transforming military operations.

The outcome of the conference could therefore shape the direction of future international negotiations on autonomous weapons and establish whether governments are prepared to place internationally agreed limits on machines capable of making lethal decisions.

For humanitarian organisations, the fundamental principle remains that responsibility for the use of lethal force must stay with human beings rather than be transferred entirely to artificial intelligence.

WhatsApp Channel